Journal of the House of Representatives
of the Second Session of the 110th General Assembly
of the State of South Carolina
being the Regular Session Beginning Tuesday, January 11, 1994

Page Finder Index

| Printed Page 3970, Apr. 5 | Printed Page 3990, Apr. 5 |

Printed Page 3980 . . . . . Tuesday, April 5, 1994

mind judiciously into the community as you expand the borders or the boundaries of the College of Charleston, cooperation among the community, among the residents in that area, the cooperative housing that you mentioned earlier where the students would go into the housing of other people is a good idea because it breeds for cooperation and coordination within the community.
Q. Thank you.
THE CHAIRMAN: Thank you, sir.
A. Thank you.
THE CHAIRMAN: I appreciate all of you coming. I believe that finishes those scheduled for today. The withdrawals, of course, delight us and cut our time down. We certainly appreciate you coming.
SENATOR MACAULAY: Mr. Chairman, I move that we recess until next week, so that we can hear all of the candidates.
SENATOR WILSON: That's Wednesday at 10:00 o'clock.
THE CHAIRMAN: Senator Macaulay moves to recess until next week, so we can hear the rest of the candidates. All in favor say aye, opposed no. They ayes have it.
(There being nothing further, the proceedings concluded at 9:30 a.m.)

Hearing of Wednesday, March 23, 1994
9:05 a.m. - 9:40 a.m.

The proceedings taken at Room 433, Blatt Building, Columbia, South Carolina, on the 23rd day of March 1994, before Elaine M. Boyd, Certified Court Reporter (ID) and Notary Public in and for the State of South Carolina.

Members:
Representative Eugene C. Stoddard, Chairman
422B, Blatt Building
Columbia, South Carolina 29211

Representative Jennings G. McAbee
522C Blatt Building
Columbia, South Carolina 29211

Representative Curtis B. Inabinett
328D Blatt Building
Columbia, South Carolina 29211


Printed Page 3981 . . . . . Tuesday, April 5, 1994

Representative H. Howell Clyborne, Jr.
503A Blatt Building
Columbia, South Carolina 29211

Senator Alexander S. Macaulay, Vice-Chairman
305 Gressette Building
Columbia, South Carolina 29211

Senator Warren K. Giese
512 Gressette Building
Columbia, South Carolina 29211

Senator Maggie W. Glover
613 Gressette Building
Columbia, South Carolina 29211

Senator Addison G. Wilson
606 Gressette Building
Columbia, South Carolina 29211

THE CHAIRMAN: Several of our committee members have other appointments this morning and will be coming in. First, I would like to thank all of you for taking an interest in your fellow man by serving with such low pay. We certainly appreciate your dedication and your interest in public service.

We're going to start this morning with those candidates who are unopposed. We have reports from SLED on all you on your background. Thankfully, you all came up positive. So as I call your name, would you please stand? Darlene Hyman. William G. Stevens. Martha S. Whitener. Glenn J. Lawhon. Morgan B. Coker. Estelle M. Mauldin. Bobby M. Bowers. We caught Ms. Mauldin last week. Thomas C. Rowland, Jr. Stanley C. Baker, Jr. Herbert C. Granger. Robert C. Lake, Jr. Margaret M. Addison. Charles C. Lewis. Bishop Johnnie M. Smith. Lord, what a list. Othniel H. Wienges. A.S. Bahnmuller. William C. Hubbard. Tony J. Lister. Donald A. Bailey. Michael J. Mungo. C. Edward Floyd. Mack I. Whittle. Is Faye Edwards present?

You may feel free to leave at any time that you desire. You'll be notified of the Screening Committee's actions in the near future. The tentative date for elections is the 13th or the 20th. We are undecided which of next month. We certainly appreciate your attendance. Thank you, ladies and gentlemen.


Printed Page 3982 . . . . . Tuesday, April 5, 1994

We will now proceed with the Medical University Seat 1. The first candidate is Dan Brake. Doctor Brake, please take the stand.
DOCTOR BRAKE: Yes, sir.
THE CHAIRMAN: Doctor, raise your right hand please.
DAN BRAKE, M.D., having been duly sworn, testified as follows:
THE CHAIRMAN: Doctor, considering your present occupation or other activities will you be able to attend board meetings on a regular basis?
A. Yes, I will, sir.
THE CHAIRMAN: Do you have any health related problems that the screening committee should be made aware of that would prevent you from serving on the board in a full capacity?
A. No, I do not.
THE CHAIRMAN: Do you now hold any public position of honor or trust that if elected to the Board would violate the Dual Office Holding clause of the Constitution?
A. No, sir.
THE CHAIRMAN: We now have Senator Giese who has joined us and our vice chairman Senator Macaulay. Gentlemen, do you have any questions of the candidate?
SENATOR GIESE: Mr. Chairman.
EXAMINATION BY SENATOR GIESE:
Q. I would ask, what leads you to offer for this position?
A. Well, I graduated from MUSC in 1962. I grew up in South Carolina in Lake City and went Wofford College and feel a real -- a close knit to the people in South Carolina. I feel a real deep affection for the medical university for allowing me to achieve my goal which was become a doctor and practice in this state.

I have some real concerns about what's happening in health care and where the health care system is heading. I feel it's extremely important that we have somebody that's knowledgeable about -- in the future of health care that can advise the medical university on -- I have served as a vice chairman of AMA delegation, South Carolina Medical Association, the AMA and am knowledgeable about what's happening all over the country. Unfortunately, we're behind California in a lot of ways, but managed care is here and primary care is scaring the medical universities and the private physicians as far as the entrance into health care.

There is a battle going on in Charleston right now as you well know that I don't think is good for the medical university or good for the private physicians. I think that the board is going to need some leadership in how


Printed Page 3983 . . . . . Tuesday, April 5, 1994

to work together to take care of the medical university as well as we need the medical university.
Q. Where do you stand on that issue?
A. Well, I stand -- I've been called by the private coalition to join them and I basically have told them that I feel like this is the wrong approach for us to take. The private physicians are scared and I mean, there's paranoia all over health care right now because we don't know what's happening. All the managed care systems are coming down.

The medical universities all over the country are seeing patients that they're getting tied into HMOs that can't come to them and they can't survive without the patients. They can't teach students without the patients. The private physicians are concerned that these networks are going to dry up their patients and they're not going to be able to survive and it's got to be a happy medium.

I don't think the private physicians should say the medical university we're just going to send you the tertiary care. They're going to have to survive. We've got to teach our primary care doctors and they'd have to deal with private patients. And since the entrance into health care as a family physician in which people really didn't realize in the past. The family physicians realized it, but now everybody realizes it, to get into any kind of subspecialty care, you've got to go through your primary care doctor first.
Q. What is your specialty?
A. I'm in family practice.
Q. So that is of considerable interest to you?
A. It certainly is. I think, you know, the medical university realizes that family practice is the interest. They are looking at family physicians as an entrance into patients into the medical university.

The private physicians in the subspecialty area are scared about losing primary care doctors because that's what feeds the subspecialty areas. And I think we can work those situations out, but we can't do the amount that it's going on in Charleston right now.
Q. Thank you.
THE CHAIRMAN: Any other questions of the doctor? Thank you, Doctor.
A. Thank you.
THE CHAIRMAN: Our next candidate for Seat 1 is Doctor Donald R. Johnson. Doctor Johnson, would you raise your hand please.
DONALD R. JOHNSON, II, M.D., having been duly sworn, testified as follows:


Printed Page 3984 . . . . . Tuesday, April 5, 1994

THE CHAIRMAN: Do you -- considering your present occupation or other activities, would you be able to attend board meetings on a regular basis?
A. Yes, I would.
THE CHAIRMAN: Do you have any health related problems that the Screening Committee should be made aware of that would prevent you from attending on a regular basis?
A. No, I do not.
THE CHAIRMAN: Do you now hold any office of public honor or trust that if elected to the board would cause you to violate the Dual Office Holding clause of the Constitution?
A. I do not.
THE CHAIRMAN: Senator, do you have any questions of Doctor Johnson?
EXAMINATION BY SENATOR GIESE:
Q. Question, do you have any thoughts about redirecting or adjusting the position that the Board of Trustees at the Medical University now has set its course on? Do you have any changes that you think should take place?
A. Well, I'm not sure if there are any changes that need to be made as much as communication that needs to be made. I'm one of the few physicians in Charleston that have been a member of the private practice extension of MUSC known as the UMA and I'm additionally in private practice on the staff of all the hospitals in Charleston, so I'm kind of sitting on a fence.

And I think because of this, there have been people in both of these different communities that have come to me and wondered if I could maybe be a bridge or liaison between these two groups.

Right -- right now unfortunately as Doctor Brake alluded to there is a very bad argument, debate, if you will, between the private practitioners in Charleston and the University. And I think it's ultimately going to hurt both groups. The only way that this can be a winning situation for the Medical University, and it must be and the private doctors is that if they work together cooperatively. And right now they're not doing that. I think that's very unfortunate.
Q. My impression is that the Medical University needs, I won't say unusual cases, but they need things to broaden the scope of the experience of the people that they're training. Have they gone beyond that, are you saying, in looking for the, let's say, mass type of patient flow to the Medical University?


Printed Page 3985 . . . . . Tuesday, April 5, 1994

A. Well, there are a couple of things that are -- that are motivating forces. To begin with, health care reform is something that the University has to respond to just as we do in private practice.

Additionally, the University hospital is a great cost center meaning that in any health care plan or health care reform, the hospital itself is going to be a driving cost to escalate prices. The University really is trying to move as all of medicine is outside of the sub-subspecialists and to come back more to primary care type medicine. And that's right now where they're extending their tentacles, if you will, and that's where they're kind of crossing paths with the private docs in the community.
Q. They're extending their tentacles sounds to me like they're going beyond the service of specialized cases to expand the experience of the -- of their students?
A. Well, I think they are doing that and I think they have to do that. And they're also expanding outside the traditional walls of the University. For instance, they are -- they're building primary care offices in other parts of the tri-county area in places that traditionally, they had not had a presence.

And so if you have a private community say Mount Pleasant, 20 miles away and then the University builds their branch there so to speak, the private docs react to that and that's -- that's the nucleus of the debate that's going on right now.
Q. Thank you very much.
THE CHAIRMAN: Any other questions?
SENATOR MACAULAY: No, Mr. Chairman.
THE CHAIRMAN: Thank you, Doctor.
A. Thank you.
THE CHAIRMAN: Next we have Seat 3 a contest in the Lander University Board. Our first candidate would be Maurice Holloway. Mr. Holloway.
MR. HOLLOWAY: Yes, sir.
THE CHAIRMAN: Would you raise your hand, please.
MAURICE HOLLOWAY, having been duly sworn, testified as follows:
THE CHAIRMAN: Considering your present occupation or other activities, will you be able to attend board meetings on a regular basis?
A. Yes, I will.
THE CHAIRMAN: Do you have any health related problems that the Screening Committee should be made aware of that would prevent you from serving in a regular basis?
A. I don't.


Printed Page 3986 . . . . . Tuesday, April 5, 1994

THE CHAIRMAN: Do you now hold any position of honor or trust that if elected to the board would violate the Dual Office Holding clause of the Constitution?
A. I do not.
THE CHAIRMAN: Gentlemen, any questions of Mr. Holloway?
EXAMINATION BY SENATOR GIESE:
Q. Are you any relative of Superintendent Holloway?
A. No, I'm not, but I do know him.
Q. Superintendent I believe down in Orangeburg?
A. I thought he had moved. Maybe not. But he was at Spring Valley area at one time. Right.
THE CHAIRMAN: Any other questions?
SENATOR MACAULAY: One, Mr. Chairman.
EXAMINATION BY SENATOR MACAULAY:
Q. Mr. Holloway, you attended, in fact, you got your degrees at Lander?
A. Right. I did, sir.
Q. Do you notice any difference from the time it was a college to now it's a university?
A. A great difference. And the fact that some of my motivation come out of the fact that my parents, we're -- they had five children. I'm the oldest of them. All five of us attended Lander and are proud about the way the University has gone and where it has taken us, so that's a lot of my motivation for being here. I want to see it impact other lives as it has impacted ours.
Q. Thank you.
A. Thank you.
SENATOR MACAULAY: No other questions.
THE CHAIRMAN: Thank you, Mr. Holloway.
A. Thank you.
THE CHAIRMAN: Our next candidate for that seat is Thomas J. Kosmata. I guess my pronunciation was close.
MR. KOSMATA: Close. Kosmata.
THE CHAIRMAN: Sir, would you raise your right hand please.
THOMAS J. KOSMATA, having been duly sworn, testified as follows:
THE CHAIRMAN: Sir, considering your present occupation or other activities, will you be able to attend board meetings on a regular basis?
A. I will.

Printed Page 3987 . . . . . Tuesday, April 5, 1994

THE CHAIRMAN: Do you have any health related problems that the Screening Committee should be made aware of that would interfere with your attendance on a regular basis?
A. No, sir, I do not.
THE CHAIRMAN: Do you now hold any public position of honor or trust that if elected to the board would violate the Dual Office Holding clause of the Constitution?
A. No, sir, I do not.
THE CHAIRMAN: Any questions, gentlemen?
EXAMINATION BY SENATOR GIESE:
Q. Mr. Kosmata, when did you come to South Carolina?
A. I relocated -- had the opportunity to relocate to South Carolina in 1972 in the development of a major industry coming into the Columbia area.
Q. And what was your major interest -- I see you have a BS in Business Administration.
A. That's correct.
Q. What area of business administration?
A. My undergraduate degree concentrated in Human Resources manager and production operations.
Q. Why are you interested in being a member of the board?
A. I've had the opportunity to recruit -- see the recruits of the higher education system for South Carolina for -- for some 20 years now. I want to have -- a dual reason, had a dual reason, to seek candidacy. One is to give back some of the cultural outreach that I've received in relocating to South Carolina and, secondly, to -- to provide some proactive business mentality, thinking and emphasis to higher education today.
Q. Thank you.
THE CHAIRMAN: Any other questions?
SENATOR MACAULAY: No, Mr. Chairman.
THE CHAIRMAN: Thank you, sir.
A. Thank you, gentlemen.
THE CHAIRMAN: Those candidates who have been interviewed, feel free to leave at any time. Finally, we get to the last one, the Citadel Board, two seats at-large and we have three candidates. Our first candidate alphabetically is James E. Jones. Senator Wilson has now joined us.
SENATOR WILSON: Thank you.

Printed Page 3988 . . . . . Tuesday, April 5, 1994

THE CHAIRMAN: Mr. Jones, would you raise your right hand, please.
JAMES E. JONES, JR., having been duly sworn, testified as follows:
THE CHAIRMAN: Mr. Jones, considering your present occupation or other activities will you be able to attend board meetings on a regular basis?
A. Yes, sir, I will.
THE CHAIRMAN: Do you have any health related problems the Screening Committee should be made aware of that would prevent you from serving on the board in a full capacity?
A. I'm aware of none.
THE CHAIRMAN: Do you now hold any public office of honor or trust that if elected to the board would violate the Dual Office Holding clause of the Constitution?
A. No, sir, I do not.
THE CHAIRMAN: Gentlemen, you have any questions of Mr. Jones?
EXAMINATION BY SENATOR MACAULAY:
Q. Mr. Jones, I understand that you are now the chairman of the Board of Visitors?
A. That is correct, Senator.
Q. Has it been an interesting time you've had to occupy that position?
A. It's been one of the most difficult times since I've been on the board, sir.
Q. And you seek reelection?
A. Yes, sir, I do.
Q. No other questions, Mr. Chairman.
SENATOR WILSON: Mr. Chairman, I'm sorry I'm late. I'm delighted to see the split today of three Senators and one House Member. That is a very fair representation.
THE CHAIRMAN: Well balanced, Senator.
SENATOR WILSON: Well balanced. But I as a Charleston native am very proud of the Citadel and I want to thank you for your service and I want to let you know that we're proud of the Citadel. And when I see the different articles about the activities at the Citadel, I think all of us are very proud of the graduation rate and what the contributions that are made to the State by your students, the cadets and your graduates and I'm very proud to have two nephews there right now and all of my sons have been attendees at the Citadel summer camp which is -- means a lot to our family, so we're very proud of what the Citadel means.
A. Thank you very much for those words, sir.

Printed Page 3989 . . . . . Tuesday, April 5, 1994

THE CHAIRMAN: Any other questions? Thank you, Mr. Jones. Our next candidate is Francis P. Mood. Mr. Mood, would you raise your right hand, please.
FRANCIS P. MOOD, having been duly sworn, testified as follows:
THE CHAIRMAN: Sir, considering your present occupation or other activities, will you be able to attend board meetings on a regular basis?
A. Yes, sir. Mr. Chairman, I tried very hard to look at the demands of the practice in other areas that I'm involved in and I have made sure that I can make the necessary commitment.
THE CHAIRMAN: Do you have any health related problems the Screening Committee should be made aware of that prevents you from serving on the board in a full capacity?
A. No, sir. I've had a physical within the last year and so far, so good.
THE CHAIRMAN: Do you now hold any position of honor or trust that if elected to the board would cause you to violate the Dual Office Holding Clause of the Constitution?
A. No, sir.
THE CHAIRMAN: Gentlemen, do you have any questions?
EXAMINATION BY SENATOR MACAULAY:
Q. Same question, I guess, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Mood, you are familiar with what the Citadel is going through now?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Do you still seek election to that Board of Visitors?
A. Yes, sir, I do. Senator, I -- as I indicated in the comments that I prefiled with the committee, I think it's a critical time in higher education, not that any time is unimportant, but for the Citadel as an institution of higher learning and for the system of higher education in general. And I -- it's -- if one is ever going to avail themselves an opportunity to serve in higher education, I think this is a challenging time to do it. I look forward to that opportunity, in fact.
Q. There is an old Chinese curse, may you get what you wish for.
A. Yes, you have to be careful because of that.
Q. Right. Right.
THE CHAIRMAN: Thank you, Senator. Any other --
SENATOR WILSON: Mr. Chairman, I'd like to point out that the persons who are here today who are seeking to serve the Citadel are all well thought of and, again, I'm delighted to see such a fine assemblage here today. And I, in fact, got to know Mr. Mood, and he probably has forgotten this, but 20 years he was out promoting long before I was elected to public office the Citadel with me, so I do know of his dedication to the Citadel.


| Printed Page 3970, Apr. 5 | Printed Page 3990, Apr. 5 |

Page Finder Index